Categories
photo politics Syria

Syria: A Police State?

Is Syria in 2008 a police state? Hard for us to say, but on a daily basis it does not seem to me that people feel under the thumb of the authorities. When asked about domestic politics people seem to speak freely (and generally favorably), there aren’t too many routine police checks on the streets or highways and the police/military presence is not overbearing, considering that there is compulsory military service (and therefore a lot of soldiers). It certainly feels freer than some other places we’ve been to, and generally not oppressive.

That said, we had an interesting experience today, and thought I would share it. It doesn’t exactly argue for Syria being a police state, but it does show that, under some circumstances, the police are quite active in keeping track of people and places.

We had a choice of a few different routes for our trip from Aleppo to Palmyra. For a desert change of pace, I thought that we would head all the way out to Deir ez-Zur, located on the Euphrates River near the Iraqi border, where we would overnight and then visit the Seleucid/Roman ruins of Dura Europos the next morning. We took a four hour bus to Deir ez-Zur, arriving late at night (and wandering for the next hour looking for a hotel that wasn’t full).

The next morning, we headed to the microbus station, where our eager taxi driver helped us locate the right minibus (the one to the town of Abu Kamal, which is on the Syrian/Iraqi border). However, the minibus driver wouldn’t let us in right away, saying that we needed to check in with the police, which had a small office at the station. We found this pretty peculiar (we never had to do it before when getting on a minibus, although regular bus and train rides generally required a check of identification), but guessed that it was because of course this was a sensitive border area.

There were three men in the small police office, and all were exceedingly friendly when we entered. There were “ahlen wa-sahlens” (“welcome,” by the far the phrase you hear most often in Syria) all around, followed by a few short questions (where we were from, where we were headed, and so forth). We were taken a bit aback when they named, in a casual though almost boastful manner, as if proudly offering proof of one’s own intelligence, the hotel we were staying in (there are at least seven or eight in town). The police officer wrote our details into a big register (not dissimilar from the process of checking into a hotel in Syria) and then handed us back to the minibus driver. We got on.

We noticed before we left that the identification numbers of the other passengers were also recorded, similar to the process for a regular (big) bus. We were somewhat surprised though, when, after all the paperwork was complete and right before leaving the station, our minibus was held up for a couple of minutes for an extra passenger, a rather fit young man, dressed casually yet vaguely seeming official, who sat in a space that is not usually occupied by passengers (at least not at the start of a route). Intuitively he seemed like ununiformed police or military, though at the time it was not clear.

[photo actually taken near Palmyra]

Dura Europos lies about a kilometer off of the main road from Deir ez-Zur to Abu Kamal, about twenty kilometers before Abu Kamal and the Iraqi border. A bit over an hour from Deir ez-Zur, we were dropped off on the main road outside of the ruins. When we got off, the young man got off the minibus as well, and asked us a few questions in English that was surprisingly good. Even given the nature of the questions (where are you from, where are you going, and so forth), the delivery seemed too perfunctory and without any apparent personal curiosity for our responses. When the minibus drove off (with him back on), we began wondering whether he wasn’t put on the minibus at the last minute to keep track of us, to make sure that we got off at our stated destination (a Roman ruin) rather than somewhere else (sensitive border areas).

From the highway, facing Palmyra Gate

We shrugged it off and toured the site. Dura Europos was founded by the Seleucids, one of the heirs to Alexander the Great’s adventures in the Near East. The city was then occupied by Parthians and then Romans, before being destroyed by the Sassanid Persians in 256 AD. The great discoveries at Dura Europos included incredibly rich, well-preserved frescoes located inside a synagogue (now in Damascus), a church (now at Yale in New Haven) and a Roman pagan temple (scattered in various places). These temples were mere blocks apart in the city, the Jewish synagogue being located literally across a small street from a temple to Adonis. And we think that we’re multicultural and tolerant now!

Within the city walls

Euphrates River valley, seen from Dura Europos

Anyway, toward the end of our visit we noticed that a local man was also looking around the site. There were very few tourists at Dura Europos (while we were there, we saw only one other pair of tourists, and some archeologists working in the brutal midday sun), but it wasn’t too suprising to see someone, and we didn’t think anything of it. Eager to get out of the sun, back to town and out to Palmyra, we started walking the kilometer or so back toward the main road, to pick up a minibus or hitch a ride.

When we were almost at the main road, we noticed that a white car had pulled up behind us. It was being driven strangely slowly (I had seen it coming a few minutes before), but we asked if they were headed to Deir ez-Zur, to see if we could get a ride. The answer was no–they seemed to indicate that they were headed the other way–and so we continued walking. When we got to the main road, however, the car, which had two occupants, just sat there at the intersection.

We were pretty annoyed because, naturally, having a car next to us, even if not ours, was likely to make it much harder for us to pick up a ride. The white car stood still at the intersection, the occupants chatting away, while a few cars passed by (including one that almost stopped for us, but then inexplicably sped up and drove by). After about ten minutes, we walked forward about a hundred meters along the main road, to put some space between us and the white car. Eventually, a minibus came, and we got in.

As we were getting situated (putting Derek and his knees in a minibus takes a bit of time), the white car drove up to the minibus flashing its headlights. The driver of the white car asked the driver of the minibus to come out, and there was a brief conversation and a paperwork exchanged. The minibus driver then read out a telephone number that was written on the minibus to the man in the white car. When the minibus driver got back in, he asked us in English, “Problem with the police?”

Our escorts

That’s when it became clear–we were being tracked by a series of ununiformed police officers (or delegates) ever since we left the bus station: first the man who road out with us, and then another man who kept an eye out for us in the ruins to ensure we got back on a vehicle to town. When we returned to the bus station, we were again temporarily detained at the police office (while our route was confirmed?)–again, all in the most friendly manner.

We mentioned this to our hotel owner in Deir ez-Zur, and he indicated that this was pretty standard practice. Because the city is located so close to a sensitive border, the police, we were told, do a daily circuit of all of the hotels to check guest registers. And, when tourists venture out of town in the direction of the Iraqi border, they a
re kept track of. The hotel owner said that the main purpose is, and I believe that it is, to make sure that foreign visitors (I suppose especially Americans, given potential problems we may face) are safe and out of danger. But I suppose a secondary purpose is to make sure that we’re harmless tourists, not engaging in any sinister activities.

Does our experience mean Syria is a police state? No, but the experience was surprising, a tiny bit unsettling and a first for us.

Categories
photo Syria

The Dead Cities

Syria has its great Roman-era ruins (foremost among them Apamea, Palmyra and Bosra, the latter two being UNESCO World Heritage Sites–post to come), but as an independent traveler perhaps even more enjoyable are the smaller Roman and Byzantine ruins referred to as the Dead Cities. Located primarily in the Belus Massif around the city of Muraat al-Numan (which is itself located an hour south of Aleppo and is the infamous site of cannibalistic atrocities by the Crusaders) and in the Hauran Plateau south of Damascus, the Dead Cities have survived in large part due to their sturdiness of construction (the stone building materials in those areas being particularly durable) and historical happenstance (relatively sudden decline and abandonment of the towns leading to a good time capsule-like state of preservation).

The Dead Cities, which number in the hundreds (!), are uniquely interesting historically because they include intact domestic and minor small-town buildings in addition to the larger, civic buildings that also survive in larger ruined cities. In the Dead Cities, you can find small churches, homes, olive presses, tombs–all the trappings of a small prosperous (Byzantine-era) country town. To the independent traveler, the Dead Cities provide endless opportunities for exploration (we spent a few days in total but a traveler with greater historical background and time could easily spend weeks). At one site, we saw that the Swiss government had aided in putting together a small circuit of a few of the Dead Cities–as a trekking/camping route, such a trip would truly excel in its opportunities for appreciating the beautiful Syrian countryside, interacting with rural locals and walking through history with essentially no other tourists in sight. We ourselves saw other tourists in only two of the Dead Cities that we visited, even though the ones we visited were among the most popular, and easily accessible by bus and taxi. In a country with fewer sites, these would be major, crowded attractions!

Another, somewhat wild, feature of the Dead Cities is that many are inhabited. After a period of what must have been total abandonment, many of the cities have been resettled in the recent past. While at some sites there is a separation between the old town and the new one, in other cities people live right among or in the ruins. In a few places we saw almost entire Byzantine-era homes, complete with paved courtyards and walls, being lived in, and in the Hauran town of Shahba, Roman-era shops still sell merchandise along a Roman paved street. It is quite incredible to see buildings nearly 2,000 years old still serving their original purpose–the original architects and construction companies would be so proud! The reuse is quite a sight, of course (as at Tartus–see my post of 4.14), but in some cases one wonders whether clearing out modern residents may be better in order to preserve the sites for future generations.

Church, Deir Samaan. Deir Samaan, located downhill from Qalaat Samaan, or the St. Simeon Church Complex (cf. my post of April 21), was founded to service pilgrims. (Sort of like Tirupathi to Tirumala, cf. my post of March 27.) Deir Samaan includes among its ruins many churches and pilgrim lodgings.

Detail of a column in Deir Samaan.

A local man pointed out to us this elaborately decorated crypt, which was not mentioned in any of our fairly detailed guides (note the stone grill on right, mostly covered by dirt and plants). The uncovered portion of the opening was just big enough to pass inside and see places for five sarcophagi, which have been removed. The man who showed us the crypt spoke very little English, but was very excited and insistent on speaking with us, repeating, “One house, one, two, three, four, five; two houses, three houses, four houses, why?” The sun was setting and for a while we had not a clue what he meant, but he was very persistent, and finally with many hand gestures and walking around we finally understood that he was asking us whether we thought that there might be more, unexcavated crypts, along the side of the same hill on which this crypt was found. I’m not quite sure why he thought we would know, but, looking at the terrain, it seemed quite possible, which we conveyed to him (many, many sites in Syria are not fully excavated). He suggested that we fund a dig!

The town of Jeradeh had towers, which may have had a defensive function (cf. my earlier post on the Diaolou of southern China).

The tower above had a cute and still-functioning stone door (note the hinges). We saw stone doors at a couple sites–they move surprisingly well, considering that they’re made of stone, and have obviously stood the test of time, but still seem rather impractical.

A well-ruined building in Jeradeh. Note the rocky terrain of the Belus Massif.

Much of the charm of the Dead Cities is that people still live in and among the ruins. In addition to Byzantine-era houses that are still lived-in, there are larger ruins that have been converted for new uses. This church in Ruweiha is now a pen for animals.

Laundry line-drying.

A monastery or lodging house, with well-preserved porticoes, outside Dana.

Street in Dana. Much like in Tartus (cf. my post of 4.14), you can make out masonry from different periods of construction.

On the left side of the street pictured above, an old arch used as the entrance to a home.

In Bara, an ancient olive press that looks as if it could restart production tomorrow. Bara is overgrown and half-hidden in forest and olive groves, giving the place a sort of Angkor Wat atmosphere.

A pyramidal Roman-era tomb, Bara.

Sarcophagi inside another pyramidal tomb, Bara. Note the crosses–while the pyramid form is originally a pagan design, its builders and occupants were Christian.

Overview of the central town square of Serjilla, fronted by a bath (left) and a tavern (right). Note the well-preserved paving of the square itself. Serjilla is the largest (and most popular) Dead City.

Christian detail, Serjilla.

Carving fragments, Serjilla. Although the best pieces have been carted off to museums, beautiful carvings lie in situ all over ruins in Syria.

Categories
photo queer Syria

Aleppo Souks

The most famous sight in Aleppo is its markets, or souks. Covering miles and miles of covered alleys (sometimes it feels like the whole old city is souk), the souks sell everything from food to fabric to hardware (and of course also souvenirs for the tourists, but those shops make up a very small portion of the markets as a whole). Some photographs:

Closed for business on Friday.

This sweets shop was located in a broader, uncovered area, allowing for this huge display.

A less crowded moment. The souks are generally quite congested during the day. Note the meat hanging for sale on right.

There are, surprisingly, still donkeys being used for transport about the souk.

Ground spice, artfully presented.

Entrance to Khan al-Sabun. The khans, or caravanserais, acted as both warehouses and lodging for traveling merchants. In Aleppo, most still serve their commercial function, and are crowded with shops along and sometimes within their courtyards.

Near closing time.

There is of course food for sale within the souk as well, for the merchants and the shoppers.

Note the built-in hooks. Other meat for sale was hung on the great doors within the souk.

This is just a photo post, for the most part, but if you have a few minutes try googling some other travelers’ blog entries on the gay vendors of the Aleppo souk. There are two shops in Aleppo being run by highly visible (even flamboyant) gay men. They seem quite open about their sexuality, at least to tourists (one young man wearing while we were there a t-shirt that said “Free Sex”), something that is quite surprising to see in the middle of conservative medieval Aleppo.

Categories
photo religion Syria

St. Simeon Stylites, or On Asceticism

Faith is a funny thing. Ideas that are laughable on any other level become absolute truth and sacred with the addition of religion. Picture yourself as an alien, or someone unaccustomed to civilization on Earth–how would the stories of some of the major religions (Hinduism, Judaism, Christianity, etc.) sound? Likely, at least some of them sound implausible to you already.

Similarly, man in his worship of the gods has done some strange things. Horrible things, too, of course, but setting those aside, the devout have concocted ideas that are simply bizarre. One of the oddest acts, perhaps, that man has performed to be closer to the gods is memorialized in the Byzantine ruins of Qalaat Samaan, or the Church Complex of St. Simeon, outside of Aleppo.

St. Simeon “Stylites” (390-459) was born in Syria and entered a Christian monastery at age 16. From the start of his monastic career, he showed a taste for athletic asceticism, including fasting for extended periods of time and fitting himself into tight spaces in which he could only stand upright (note the similarity to forms of torture!). Eventually his feats of privation led to fame, which he tried to escape by climbing and living atop a pillar. As his fame grew, so did his pillar, which grew to a peak height of 15 meters, at the top of which sat a railed platform that was his entire living space. From his pillar, he would speak to his adoring crowds, who made pilgrimage by the thousands to his pillar outside Aleppo. St. Simeon by the end of his career was famous throughout the Roman world, even the Emperor seeking his advice on theological matters. By his death, he had lived 37 years (!) on his pillar, and sparked hundreds of copy-cat stylites, or pillar-living ascetic monks.

The rock visible through the left central door is said to be what remains of the pillar, which has been cut down by souvenir-hunters. The large church complex was built around the pillar after St. Simeon’s death.

My introduction to this post aside, I like to think that had I been born in a different time and place, I might have been a monk, and asceticism appeals to me. It makes perfect sense to me that to seek retreat into the nonphysical realm one must withdraw from the physical, including by refraining from pleasures of the body, which act as distractions, focusing one’s attention on the senses and placing one more in the body than within the mind. For a shorter-term example, think about the darkness and silence that is standard for many places of worship, or libraries, for that matter. I have never been in a sensory deprivation tank, but I think the fundamental idea is the same–by placing yourself in darkness, as far as the inputs of the material world are concerned, you concentrate on the mental/spiritual. Asceticism also contributes to the spiritual life in terms of longer-term life goals. Vows of chastity and poverty, for example, seek to eliminate from a person’s agenda perhaps mankind’s two greatest personal pursuits, leaving more time for contemplation and the life of the mind. Asceticism, by shifting priorities, creates time and energy for different kinds of accomplishment.

Original floor tiling in the main basilica.

The asceticism of St. Simeon, however, seems to me somewhat different than the monastic ideal that I describe in the previous paragraph. Rather than mere withdrawal from pleasure, this is a type of asceticism that is focused on the creation of pain. Instead of quieting bodily signals, in order to focus on thoughts disconnected from the body, this second type of asceticism seeks to generate a bodily response, to a spiritual end. Living on top of a narrow and exposed pillar, starving for extended periods of time, wearing deliberately uncomfortable clothing, whipping oneself–these are all methods of this second kind of asceticism. Why? Doesn’t this have the opposite effect, distracting oneself with pain and discomfort, similar to the distraction of bodily pleasure? One might answer that the pain punishes the body, which is essentially evil, or that the discomfort acts to stimulate/guide thoughts as a reminder of the power of god (and perhaps his ability to damn us to eternal pain should we not conform to his teachings) or the suffering of martyrs. Or, in the case of shorter-term discomfort, such as the daytime fast of the Islamic holy month of Ramadan, the breaking of the fast each night can serve to heighten our appreciation for god’s gifts to us (of life and food). [I also suppose in an anticlerical mood one could argue that certain individuals actually derive perverse pleasure from the self-generated pain.]

Categories
photo Syria

Aleppo Citadel

I read somewhere that the Citadel of Aleppo, topologically, started as a small rise, and grew to the relative mountain it is today through numerous phases of construction, as succeeding generations and empires constructed their temples and forts upon it, each by breaking down and filling in, or adding upon, the deposits of their predecessors. The Citadel thus represents thousands of years of human history, layer piled upon layer.

Within the walls.

And so, I believe, does each of us, or rather the imprint of culture on each of our minds. Most everything we know and believe and feel comes from the past: ancient, even pre-human, biases and tendencies; the wisdom of prophets, philosophers and scientists, passed down from parent to child, professor to student, priest to acolyte; ideas in various states of preservation, from integral cataloged wholes to mere fragments, the history and genesis long forgotten; ancient thinking persisiting and integrated into new frameworks, innovations on foundational edifices long standing, concepts grafted onto others. How often is it that you read a work from hundreds of years ago, and feel it personally, feel that it expresses thoughts you’ve had or ideas you didn’t know how to express?

This is why it is worth studying history, for it explains not only the origin of peoples, places and things, but of ourselves, the structure and content of our minds, why we think the way we do and how we have come to believe what we believe. For yes there are some absolutes, but much more is a construction accreted over time, many layers of the past supporting even the loftiest towers.

Categories
photo Syria

Child Labor

Children have of course been used as a source of labor for time immemorial. Whether helping with the harvest or performing more domestic chores, they act as a pair of hands that eases the burden on the adults of a household, whose responsibilities are multiplied by the existence of the children. Even today, to watch a boy herding sheep does not spark outrage, and such work does not seem a crime to their youth and innocence.

But seeing children work in more commercial settings–on streets, in stores or in factories–this brings out a sense of pity. Sad to report, we found many instances of child labor in Syria, some more objectionable than others. What we saw here is not the horrific, industrialized abuse that one imagines when hearing similar reports in other parts of the developing world (although in all our travels in Asia we have almost never witnessed such use of child labor), but smaller scale. To our eyes and hearts, however, each such sight was still a depressing and at times even shocking encounter.

As night falls. This small child was selling sweets on an overpass outside of the old city of Damascus.

We found these three boys in a small candy/sweets factory. Of the fifteen or so employees, most were boys between the ages of twelve and eighteen or so, giving the whole place a Willy Wonka feel. The youngest ones are separating out little paper cups that are used for packaging.

This young cobbler was working in a shoe workshop with two adults. I suppose he may have been one of their sons (or perhaps a nephew), but the somewhat grim basement setting, along with the assembly-line nature of the work, left us uneasy. [Given the medieval setting of Aleppo, it’s not hard to think of some of the child labor as apprenticeships. In medieval Bukhara, Uzbekistan, we ran into a small furniture workshop staffed with young men/boys described as a woodworking school and in Cambodia and South India, we have seen crafts for sale made by “young art students.”]

Ferrying goods into a khan, or caravanserai.

On a lighter note–kids helping tend the shops of their parents. Part child labor, part cheap daycare. (I sometimes helped my parents as a young boy, though certainly not as a regular “job.”) We frequently saw the boy juicer minding the shop alone; the boy grocer looked more like he was visiting after school. It was cute, I must admit, when little children would ask us what we needed, trying to explain the price of the merchandise.

Categories
photo Syria

Crusader Castles

For almost two hundred years, from the late 11th to the late 13th centuries, western Europeans maintained a presence in the Levant through the Crusades. A series of Christian holy wars triggered largely by the Seljuk Turks’ Anatolian advances (that is, a Muslim empire encroaching on the Byzantine capital of Constantinople now Istanbul), the Crusades before they were over resulted not only in decidedly un-Christian atrocities in the Holy Land, but also in a perverse attack on Constantinople itself, the western Roman Catholics pillaging in the Fourth Crusade the Orthodox Christian imperial city. (Constantinople would finally fall, to the Ottomans, in the 15th century.)

Brief chronology:

1096 – Crusaders arrive in the Middle East.
1099 – Crusaders take Jerusalem, taking advantage of a lack of unity in the Muslim forces. Residents of Jerusalem (including many Christians) are slaughtered. Several small Crusader states are formed in the Levant.
1171 – Saladin conquers Shiite Fatimid caliphate in Egypt and forms a stronger, unified Arab force.
1187 – Battle of Hattin. Saladin captures Jerusalem, reducing the Crusader presence to a string of coastal cities, principally Acre.
1260 – Ayubbid dynasty (founded by Saladin) is replaced by the Mamluk Sultanate. The Mamluks were a slave military class of Turkish origin and rose to power by coup. The first Mamluk Sultan was Baibars, who fought off not only the Crusaders but the Mongols, stopping their advance in Syria.
1291 – Fall of Acre (and Tortosa).

Some of the greatest architectural remnants of the Crusaders are their forts. Some built on preexisting Byzantine or Arab forts, and all eventually controlled by the victorious Arabs, the castles are some of the world’s finest, not only in their magnificent structure and use of military technology but also in their spectacular locations. We visited several sights, but will focus on a few below. [Please also refer to my earlier post on Tortosa]

Krak des Chevaliers (Qalaat al-Hosn)

Undoubtedly the greatest of the Crusader castles, and in a fine state of preservation, the Krak was the site of a castle since at least the early 11th century, but was expanded by the Crusaders in the mid-12th century, when it was under the control of the Knights Hospitaller. The Krak formed part of a defense network that spanned the Crusader coast and the hinterlands, and was twice successfully defended. Mamluk Sultan Baibars led a final siege of the castle in 1271, after which the Crusaders surrendered.

Machicolations at the top of the tower, a defensive structure allowing the dropping of missiles or hot liquid on an attacking force. Note the band of Arabic inscription.

Entry to the castle, a gradual slope allowing for horses to make their way to the giant stables.

Moat and glacis, or protective slope, of the central keep, all within the outer walls. The glacis is 25 meters thick (!) at its base.

The gothic loggia. Crusader castles are generally devoid of ornamentation, making it all the more striking to see this beautiful entry to the great hall. The gothic style is a very tangible reminder that the Crusaders were, in fact, European. Outside the window you can see the central courtyard of the inner castle.

Close-up of door of loggia to the great hall (on right of picture above).

This cavernous space behind the great hall connects the kitchen area to the chapel. The open stalls visible on the left are old latrines.

The chapel was converted into a mosque in the Arab period, when the mihrab (prayer niche, to the right) and minbar (pulpit) were added on the southern (Mecca-facing) wall. The chapel, of course, faces east.

Chastel Blanc (Safita)

On a peak visible from both the Krak and Tortosa, Chastel Blanc was a link in the Crusaders’ defense. After it was damaged in an attack by Saladin in 1188, the Knights Templar took control of Chastel Blanc (along with Tortosa), and refortified it into the seemingly almost solid cube it remains today. The castle was also won by Baibars in 1271. The central keep, which acted as the chapel of the fort, survives and is now an Orthodox church.

Margat (Qalaat Marqab)

On a breathtaking ridge overlooking the Mediterranean, Margat, originally an Arab fort, was strengthened by the Knights Hospitaller in the late 12th century. After successfully withstanding two sieges, the castle was surrendered to Sultan Qalaun (successor to Baibars) in 1285.

Remnant of a fresco (uncovered in 1987) of Jesus and his disciples visible on the ceiling of a side chapel of the fort’s chapel. (This photo was obtained by Derek squeezing his camera arm up to his shoulder through a very small open window and clicking blindly at the ceiling, the same way he confirmed that these frescos were indeed there.)

Saone (Qalaat Saladin)

Saone is an earlier construction, and has been renamed for Saladin, who took the castle in 1188. While not in the same state of preservation as some of the other castles, it is unique in having many identifiable works from the Byzantine, Crusader and Arab periods, and is located in beautiful woodland, with two canyons running up each side of the narrow fort.

Remnant of rock-cut support to the drawbridge. On the left you can see a metal platform that indicates where the drawbridge entered the castle.

A giant cistern (note the steps on the right).

The outer walls, but on top of solid rock.

Categories
photo religion Syria

The Real Syria

When we tell people that we’re American, one of the things we are told is that we must go back and tell people what Syria is like, to combat ignorance and misperception. This post aims to fulfill this repeated request.

***

Coming to Syria, I had of course done some research. I knew the basic history of Syria, at least from ancient times to the Ottoman period, and knew which historical monuments I was most interested in seeing. We also very much looked forward to our reception by the Syrians, who we were told were, even by Middle Eastern standards, famous for their hospitality and the genuine warmth with which they treat foreign visitors. But there were, I am embarrassed to admit, many things about Syria I didn’t understand, and for purposes of this post I must explicitly address my ignorance. Travel at its best acts to lift such veils from our eyes, and I am thankful for my newfound understanding and hope that you find it a worthy read, even if you do not suffer from my prior shortcomings.

Syria has a secular government.

Because Syria is so often mentioned in the same breath as Iran (in U.S. foreign policy and media), and because it has supported Islamist groups outside its borders (most famously Hezbollah, the Party of God, in Lebanon), I was under the mistaken impression that Syria was politically Islamic. I didn’t think that it was a quasi-theocracy, but I did think that its government would have a more Islamic bent than other Arab countries and that its people would be more rigidly orthodox.

This could not be further from the truth. Syria’s government is almost totally secular and Islam has no special status under Syrian law (contrary to most other Arab countries). The president of Syria, Bashar al-Assad, is, like his father Hafez (president, 1971-2000), an Alawite, a religious minority that is derived from Islam but which some Muslims believe to be a heresy, and the Assads have given a fair amount of power to Alawites and other religious minorities in the Syrian government. If anything, Islamists have been viewed as a threat to the regime, and Syria has already fought and won its war against Islamist militants: In 1982, in a huge show of force called the Hama Massacre (and a massacre it was, with up to 20,000 dead), the Syrian government wiped out the Syrian branch of the Muslim Brotherhood–even today, they are active in almost every Islamic country but Syria.

The Assads even use pagan iconography! Bashar as Sun God. [More images of Assads Sr. and Jr. to come in a future post]

Every Christian we have spoken to in Syria (and we have spoken to many–although a 10% or so minority I think they speak English or choose to speak to us disproportionately) states unequivocally that all religions are equal under Syrian law and that they have no issues whatsoever with freedom of worship. In this regard, they truly feel themselves fortunate to live in Syria rather than other Arab countries. People of different faiths seem to get along perfectly well and there are many interfaith friendships, even if they do not intermarry.

Mass, Armenian church, Aleppo

[A secular, developing Arab country, firmly governed–as a couple Iraqi refugees explained to us, Syria must be what Iraq was like, before we attacked. If we’re so keen on stopping Islamofascism or whatever, why are we targeting the secular countries?]

Arab does not equal Muslim.

Because the religion of Islam arose out of Arabia, and is so closely connected to Arab ethnicity and the Arabic language, it is easy to fall into the misunderstanding that all Arabs are Muslim and most Muslims Arabs. Of course the latter is not true (from Iran westward lives a huge percentage of the world’s Muslim population, including Iranians (who are not Arabs), South Asians, Indonesians, Central Asians and Chinese Muslims), but it’s also important to keep in mind all of the Arabs that are not Muslims.

Orthodox Christian procession, Aleppo

In Syria there are very large numbers of Arab Christians (some 10% of the population), belonging to numerous faiths (Greek Orthodox, Greek Catholic and Maronite perhaps foremost among them). They form a sizable and visible minority in major cities and even a majority in certain towns. Syria has some of the world’s oldest Christian communities, given its proximity to the Holy Land, including in Maalula, where the local population still speaks Aramaic, the language that was spoken by Jesus. My namesake Paul was famously converted in Damascus, many important early saints and theologians lived their lives in Syria and Syria was a core part of the Christian Byzantine empire until the time of the Arab Islamic conquest (a testament to this being, in addition to the living churches, the huge numbers of religious sites and churches that lie among the Byzantine, and older, ruins).

Statue of Mary and crosses, Maalula

Even after the region came under the control of the caliphs, Christians prospered (freedom of worship for Christianity and Judaism is a core Islamic practice, as the three faiths all worship the same god) and formed a significant percentage of the population. In the twentieth century, because of Syria’s continuing tolerance and secular government, many Christians (ranging from Armenians fleeing Turkey to Iraqi refugees fleeing war) have sought refuge here, expanding the local Christian population.

Many faiths are represented in the Christian district of Aleppo.

Syria excels in the amount of apparent harmony there is among different religious groups, but there are also large Christian populations in other Arab countries. Lebanon was originally created by the French to be a majority Christian Arab country, and the Copts form a sizable minority in Egypt (one of my closer friends in high school came from a Coptic family). Christians make up a significant minority in Palestine as well. This may be stating the obvious, but Arab Christians are just as Arab as Arab Muslims, culturally (although Christian women may dress less modestly), linguistically (using the Arabic language for worship, including the Arabic word for god, Allah) and ethnically (that is, you cannot “tell them apart”).

[It is important to note here, although the topic really merits a separate post, the extent to which Christian and Muslim Arab opinion on the issue of Israel is essentially the same–for Arabs, the Israeli issue is not fundamentally a religious one but a national and political one; in fact, given that Israel grants citizenship to all Jews regardless of national origin, enlarging the Israeli population and arguably displacing both Muslim and Christian Arabs from their ancestral homes, some people we have spoken to see the Jewish position as the fundamentally religion-based one, perhaps somewhat contrary to what people think in America, which is that the Arabs must be the ones who are religiously driven. Especially seeing the bizarre support by some American evangelical Christians for Israel, it is tempting to agree that Zionism is far more faith-based than the Arab position.]

Syria is as much a part of the Mediterranean world as it is a part of the Middle East.

Though I, not having traveled much in southern Europe, cannot make this observation definitively as to lifestyle, it seems to me evident in the diet and character of the people, the terrain and of course history, that Sy
ria can be viewed as part of the Mediterranean world. The staples here include olives and cheese, and the cuisine is of the universal mediterranean variety that one finds in the Levant, Turkey and Greece. People are expressive and in appearance (and often dress, as far as the men are concerned) no different than southern Europeans. [Post on this to come.] The hillsides surrounding the Crusader castles reminded me far more of southern France than I thought they would, leading me to think that the Crusaders may not have felt so far from home after all. And, historically, the region has been oriented westward toward the sea (as part of the worlds of the Phoenicians, Romans, Byzantines, Crusaders) as much as east- and southward toward Iran and Arabia (and has often been a balancing point between the two).

In the souk

Countryside near Krak des Chevaliers (in upper right)

Syria is ethnically diverse.

There are two points here. The first is that there are significant and visible ethnic minorities in Syria, including Kurds (2 million, or about 10%) and Armenians (100,000). While they all speak Arabic and are integrated into the country (identify themselves as Syrians), they often know their ancestral tongue and participate in their own cultures. One Kurdish driver we hitched a ride with (Kurds are sometimes quick to identify themselves as Kurds, even unsolicited) proudly blasted loud Kurdish music. Other Kurds we have met were eager to discuss our perception of Kurds. Armenians are united not only by ethnicity but by their faith, and can be seen attending church services. Unlike the Kurds (who to us are not easily identified by appearance), Armenians tend to be fair in coloration and somewhat easier to distinguish. One Armenian woman explained to us how flights from Aleppo (the main home of the Armenian community in Syria) to Yerevan were always full and hard to book.

A Kurdish woman

Armenian youth outside an Armenian church in Aleppo

The second point, and I think the more interesting one, is that “Arab” ethnic identity is far more complicated than I imagined. Unlike in the Gulf, where Arab carries with it a certain homogeneous outward appearance, Arab people in Syria have very diverse appearances. This must be because of the many, many peoples who have flowed in and out of the area over time, and gradually become assimilated to Arab language, culture and identity. The Arab armies at the time of the Arab conquest, after all, did not massacre and replace the local population–it is that the (largely already Semitic) people who were here became Arabized over time (not to mention the people who arrived after the Arab conquest–presumably there are descendents of Crusaders and Mongols in Syria). Color in terms of skin, hair and eyes varies widely, far more widely than I expected–so much so, that there are people here who could pass for almost any caucasian ethnic group, from Indian to northern European (who knew we would see so many redheads in the Middle East!). [Post on this to come.]

Traditional dress does not indicate a puritanical mindset.

Does not really illustrate the point, but a fun picture–the women apologized for getting in the way, although of course they were an essential part of the composition.

I think, before coming here, I had a sense that people who dressed in very traditional Arab Islamic clothing must take themselves (and their religion) very seriously, and so were so pious as to be un-fun. It seemed that people who wanted to set themselves apart from the modern world in such manner must want also to keep their distance from outsiders and their ways. While it is true that a woman wearing a burka is likely to be fairly reserved and cautious in her interactions with a foreign man, many people we’ve met in what in the West would be considered some form of Islamic dress have not at all matched the stereotype that I held.

At play in the courtyard of the Grand Mosque in Aleppo

A friendly cleric outside the Grand Mosque in Aleppo

In terms of behavior, wearing a veil here in Syria seems to predict almost nothing. Young women in Syria wear all sorts of modern western clothing (often tight, though not exposing much skin), and sometimes accessorize with a sexy scarf to cover the head (often topped with a pair of trendy sunglasses). The “veil”, though perhaps dictated by custom, merely becomes another accessory and not one that defines their modern outlook. And some of these young ladies are among the most flirtatious in the world!

A modern Syrian woman, Aleppo

A group that we met at Apamea. The young ladies, though dressed in black, were very made up and sexy. As they passed us, they asked us (in Arabic) to take their pictures (as many Syrians do). When we took the camera out, however, the older woman who was with them (a teacher?) scolded them and tried to block us, while the girls kept trying to evade her and get photographed. Even after they passed us, they kept looking back and giving us very, um, warm, smiles.

Similarly, we’ve met older women in full black dress who are incredibly friendly and even playful, sometimes encouraging their children and even daughters to interact with us and practice the English they’ve been learning. Derek swears that a woman in a burka shot him with a squirtgun at the Aleppo Citadel.

Waving hello, Aleppo Citadel

Enjoying an ice cream in the Damascus souk (incidentally, the ice cream, which is from a very famous store called Bekdach, is horrible). This woman posed for Derek for what must have been at least thirty clicks.

Categories
photo Syria

Amrit, or Encounter with the Bedouin

So often in travel (and perhaps in life) you set out to do one thing, and end up discovering something else en route, an experience that ends up overshadowing your original plan. Travel at its best is often this way, when sightseeing plans end up acting as a mere framework for you to have a genuine cultural experience, the kind that cannot be planned on an itinerary.

Finding ourselves on the coastal town of Tartus (former Tortosa, city of the Knights Templar–please refer to other post) with a morning at our disposal, we set out for the ancient Phoenician ruins of Amrit a few kilometers south. The Phoenicians, in the centuries before Christ, dominated the Levant and controlled cities all over the Mediterranean. While their other cities, including Arwad, an island just off the coast of Tartus and the final base of the Crusaders, were subsequently inhabited and redeveloped by other civilizations, Amrit remained a ruin after the Phoenicians’ departure, providing a more time capsule-like view into their culture. I knew that Amrit was more of a religious center than a great city, and that the ruins remaining are few and scattered, but I was curious to see the site from having always seen mention of the Phoenicians in history books and atlases, but not knowing much about them (perhaps because, despite their great seafaring prowess and wide distribution, they, unlike the Romans, the Greeks or the Persians, do not remain as a nation).

We negotiated with a taxi driver to take us to Amrit, and thought that we were on track as we headed south on the coastal road out of Tartus–but much more quickly than I expected we ended up at a dead-end, a roundabout terminating in a military base. The driver stopped the car to inquire directions of the soldiers. Now, I had read in guidebooks that the ruins of Amrit are mixed in with military installations, which makes access to some of the ruins impossible and photography problematic, but I had not thought that we would run into soldiers before we got to any of the ruins. But no problem–the soldiers were friendly and a particularly well-built one, fresh from swimming or diving in a wetsuit that was now half off, instructed us in his hearty voice to proceed on foot through the military area. A local farmer (?) who happened to be nearby set off with us, and we bid our taxi farewell.

After the first few hundred meters, it became clear that the driver had taken the wrong road, but having faith in the soldier who said that the ruins were reachable by foot, we proceeded forward with our non-English speaking impromptu guide. He briefly stopped to point out to us a giant sarcophagus dug out in a trench, and we knew we were on the right track. Soon we came to a dirt road and a sign and within sight of the ruins of the main temple complex. We bid our farmer goodbye (with baksheesh, or tip) and walked toward the temple, which we had read was dedicated to a local god who was something like Hercules. Built from the sixth century BC, and in active use for centuries afterward, it consisted of a small central shrine within a large compound which is said to have been flooded. Nearby was a extremely long and skinny (230x30m) largely rock-cut stadium, presumably used for very narrow games (running?) and according to tourist literature able to seat over 10,000 spectators.

Central shrine, or cella, of temple

Stadium (note person on left for scale)

From there the real adventure began. The next sites to the south were monumental towers erected over burial chambers, but we didn’t know how to get there. There were some unpaved roads running alongside the temple ruins, yes, but it was not entirely clear whether they would lead to the next set of ruins, and whether cutting through the trees might provide quicker, more shaded access for those traveling by foot. Armed with my vague map, we headed due south. In part because they are tall, the towers were pretty easy to find. One had an unusual cylindrical shape, with odd ornamentation, and each had a surprising number of niches for bodies underneath.

Towers (note person on left tower for scale)

There, we met there a tour guide who was taking an elderly Swiss couple around the ruins. He offered us a ride back to town, but we thanked him and told him that we wanted to explore more of Amrit, including a third, shorter hulking tower nearby. The guide warned us that we were venturing too close to active military areas, jokingly saying that as Americans we would have our hands chopped off if we were caught in the wrong place. Of course, we knew no such thing would happen to us, but Syria being something of a police state (related post to come), we were unsure how cautious we should really be. When we told the guide that we would risk it, he more strongly counseled us against.

We wanted to see the third tower, but also didn’t want to risk detention or arrest–and so we decided to sneak up to the third tower via a circuitous path, which also allowed us first to chat with some picnicking Syrian college students (and pose for the obligatory “photos with foreigners” shoot). As we got closer, it was clear that the tower itself acted as part of a barrier to a small compound that was delineated by barbed wire. About fifty meters from the tower were two large artillery guns, and some slowly spinning radars, and I could see one soldier walking about. We got a little closer, but did not risk lingering or taking photographs (though I think the soldier near the gun must have seen us, and didn’t care that we were poking around.)

We continued on, to see a large cubic mausoleum mentioned in my guide. Although we were not quite sure whether the next fence we encountered meant we were inside or outside of a restricted area, we saw a large road nearby and so figured that we were either out of the military base or at least out of the areas closed to the public. The bigger problem was that I didn’t know how to get to the site, which I knew was about a kilometer away. Trees blocked our sight and the trails that there were were curvy and indirect. We walked about, through fields and roads, asking directions when we could but not getting much useful information (I tried in Arabic the name of the site, the word for tower and the word for cube, and a number of hand gestures to indicate what we were looking for–all to no avail).

Just when we had come upon a man who spoke some English and seemingly confidently pointed us in the right direction, we came upon the bedouins.

Now, bedouins are all over the Arab world. We have met bedouins in the deserts of Oman, and been invited to sit with them and drink cardamon-flavored coffee (they are, of course, famous for their hospitality, even among the general Arab population). But seeing Bedouins on the green Syrian coast felt strange because we were not in the wilderness, not in the desert which intuitively seems the bedouins’ natural domain. Also, this experience was new because the group that we ran into was doing something that we knew bedouins to do, but something we had not seen them doing: moving. It being the twenty-first century, the family was using a large flatbed truck, not camels or other pack animals, but their belongings were much the same as they would have been thousands of years ago–wooden poles for their tent home, canvas for the tent itself, large numbers of quilts and mats, kitchen implements and so forth. The younger men and women were unloading the truck, while children played about and the leader of the group, an elderly man in traditional dress with well-weathered skin, directed.

We lingered to see this ritual, and tried to communicate with the old man, who was quite friendly. There were so many questions
we wanted to ask, though of course we had no language in common: How often do you move each year? Do you go to the same places? How many of you live together? Doesn’t this land belong to somebody? We didn’t get the answers to these questions, but got some descriptions of the family relationships among the people present, and the (obvious) answer to perhaps my biggest question: Why still nomadic? The answer was in the form of hundreds of bleating sheep, lambs, goats and kids. Herded by mule and teenage boys, they crowded the field nearby, walking and grazing packed tight together, some looking wise and old, others mere nursing infants. The bedouin were moving for the same reason they always have–to find pasture for their flock.

It’s strange to see such historical continuity. We often think of the nomadic life as something of the past, a stage that humans went through on the way to life on farms and in cities. It becomes somewhat comprehensible in some extreme places, like the deserts of Arabia or the mountains of Central Asia, where cultivation, or year-round habitation, for climatic reasons, is not feasible. But it seems like a pattern that should not hold out, that whenever possible should give way to sedentary life. But here the bedouin were, mere hours by car from the world’s oldest continuously inhabited cities. The bedouins’ ancestors, for hundreds and thousands of years, had rubbed shoulders and traded, shared much the same space, as urbanized people.

In theory, to my biased mind, it seems unlikely–but it is a historical fact, and one of the things that make this part of world so unique. With the fertile coast and river valleys lying so close to desert and emptiness, it is a boundary between two worlds. In the case of the bedouin, it’s the boundary between the urban Mediterranean world and the Arabian desert, where nomads in tents and rich merchants in opulent homes have coexisted. [An old map I saw in an exhibit in Aleppo showed a bedouin encampment outside of the eastern gate–that is of course the direction they would arrive from, the direction of the desert. We found that near that gate still sell good for bedouins, like tent poles stakes.] In other contexts, and at other times, Syria has lain between Egyptian and Hittite, Greco-Roman and Persian, Christian and Muslim, Mongol and Mamluk, and so on.

A family portrait

The lady of the house, tattooed (like in so many other “tribal” cultures)

After talking with the older man and taking pictures of his family (they were very patient with Derek), we walked over to the field to observe the animals. There, we were invited for tea with a man and two younger boys, boiled over a open fire.

One of these boys joined us in our quest for the final mausoleum. We had thought that a young boy would certainly have explored the area and know instantly what we wanted–but no such luck (perhaps asking a nomad for local monuments isn’t the best idea). We wandered with the children (for at times others joined us) for almost an hour, finding some other minor ruins but not the mausoleum, even scouting fruitlessly from the roof of an inhabited house. Eventually, we bid the children goodbye and searched alone. When we had almost given up, we ran into another rather muscular half-naked man on a motorcycle, this time tattooed and for some reason mostly covered with sand, who knew where the structure was and told us to get on his bike. We stopped a few minutes later, and he indicated that we should go through a break in the fence of an orchard on the side of the dirt road. (Coincidentally, this was the same orchard that Derek had “borrowed” a couple of oranges from about twenty minutes earlier, but did not go far enough to see the mausoleum.)

The men tending the orchard didn’t seem to mind our visit, and helped us pick fruit from the best of the many trees, before walking us toward the tall tower.

Mausoleum (note person for scale on right)

Categories
photo Syria

Tortosa

Before we began our trip, we downloaded from iTunes and watched a brief made-for-television program on some of the largest Crusader structures in Syria, including the Hospitaller fort of Krak des Chevaliers (post to come) and the Templar city of Tortosa (now Tartus). From this program we knew that Tartus existed as a modern Syrian city that has in part grown up within the ramparts of the old walled city, its Crusader remnants often visible through the more recent layers of construction. Even after seeing it on video, however, we were still not prepared for this merging of old and new.

Tartus was separately established as a city during the reign of Emperor Constantine in the 4th century, when it was distinguished from the older settlement on the island a few miles ashore, Arwad, which was an important city since at least Phoenician times. In the 7th century, the city was one of the conquests of the newly-Islamic Arabs, under whose control it remained until the Crusader invasion at the end of the 11th century. For most of the period from 1099 to 1291, the city was held by the Crusaders, with the Knights Templar assuming responsibility for the city in 1152. Saladin almost retook the city in 1188, but the Templars managed to hold on, and after Saladin’s departure reconstructed and fortified the city’s great cathedral, Our Lady of Tortosa, which was originally constructed in 1123.

Interior of Our Lady of Tortosa, now a museum

The fortification of the church was accompanied by enhanced fortifications of the walled city as well, which strong walls have survived encroaching homes over the last eight hundred years. Tortosa formed part of the series of defenses that ran along the Crusader-held coast and immediate hinterlands. Tortosa finally fell in 1292, after the Arabs had already conquered the great inland castles (post to come) and Tyre down the coast. Tortosa was the last Crusader hold on the mainland, although they would remain on offshore Arwad until 1302, purportedly to stage a renewed attack (which never took place, much like attacks on the Chinese mainland prepared on the island of Taiwan).

Of course, it’s perfectly natural in the course of the life of a city to build upon existing foundations, and this happens with almost every city. Buildings accumulate, and pieces of many eras are often on full simultaneous display. But this presentation, for reasons not quite clear to me, seems exaggerated at Tartus, where so much of the Crusader city layout (interior and exterior walls, moats) and pieces of several Crusader structures (donjon or keep, chapel) are, by their durable and distinctive masonry, easy to identify in the residential old city. For the most part, I think it speaks to the solidity of Crusader construction, and the lack of an organized effort by the inhabitants that followed to build competitive structures–most construction in the old city since Crusader times, it seems, has been relatively haphazard and minor, at times dismantling part of or building into the Crusader framework but never coming close to its permanence or scale. (The old city, of course, is only part of the story–most of the modern city of Tortosa lies outside the small enclosure of the city walls.)

Houses built into the Crusader chapel. In the documentary that we saw, I believe that these houses were occupied but they are now empty–a local man told us that the government has been gradually clearing (parts of?) the old city to be refurbished and maintained as a historical site and tourist attraction.

Houses built into the wall of what was once a vaulted hall.

Houses built into the exterior wall of the city. The inhabitants of Tartus have over the past 800 years superimposed their homes onto the foundations and blocks of the original wall–the moat is clearly discernible all around the exterior wall, as are the former towers.

A closeup of the wall. You can see the large Crusader blocks on the bottom, as well as older homes made of smaller blocks of stone and newer homes made of concrete.

Homes built into the interior wall. The street lies in the space between the interior and exterior (concentric) walls.

The wall of the city facing the sea. You can see the slope, or glacis, that was part of the defensive structure of the city.

By the time we arrived in Tartus, we had already seen several castles that we knew were once inhabited in this manner (castles that had villages spring up within their walls, which villages were later cleared), and so it was particularly interesting to see a contemporary example. Old Tartus is very much a living place, with clothes hanging to dry from windows, children playing in the narrow alleys and old men smoking nargileh in the town square.